Tuesday's Tip: Software Licensing and Pricing - Get Rid of CPI Escalation Clauses In Maintenance

December 1, 2008

Consumer Price Index clauses represent additional costs of ownership that should be avoided.  Maintenance typically represents 2 times the cost of the original license fees after 10 years of ownership.  Many customers have these CPI clauses in their contracts.  In the worst cases, customers may have signed CPI + X%.  CPI adjustments provide very little value to the customer and their increases are often not used for reinvestment in the product line the charges are based from.  Some suggestions to increase vigilance in reducing unnecessary vendor imposed fees:

  • Eliminate the CPI clause. Take it out of contracts.  Eliminate the uncertainty all together.  The cost of supporting customers over time goes down with time and there really is no need for a CPI clause in your contract.
  • Include language for negative CPI. If the best is that deflation will occur, specify in the contract that a negative CPI indicator will lead to a decrease in maintenance fees.
  • Lock down a fixed maintenance price for the life of the relationship.  Take the hassle out of all maintenance fee increases.  Some vendors have honored life time maintenance fee agreements.  With the economy the way it is, we are seeing some vendor starting to rehonor such agreements.

The bottom line.
In a recent survey of major software vendors, 27 of 29 vendors have canceled their initiatives to raise maintenance fees for 2008 and 2009.  While outward increases are not common, the CPI escalation clause is a "stealth" way to increase maintenance on existing customers over time.  As inflationary fears are being replaced by deflationary worries, enterprises in the midst of contract negotiations should change how vendors adjust maintenance fees and eliminate CPI outright or seek a concession that limits these increases.
Your POV.
Got a tip for optimizing existing software contracts?  You can post here or send me a private email to [email protected].
(Added 3/5/2009) Take the new poll on what rights should be in the 2009 Enterprise Software Licensee Bill of Rights!
Copyright © 2008 R Wang. All rights reserved

Cupertino Ray Wang Ray R Wang Amitive Community Centric SaaS supply chain Monday's Musings activity feeds Activity streams feeds social feeds social streams Aneel Bhusri Cloud cloud computing disruptive disruptive technologies disruptive technology Executive Profiles R "Ray" Wang; rwang0 Software Insider SoftwareInsider Thursday's Tech Showcase WorkDay BunchBall Constellation Research enterprise applications enterprise apps Enterprise Software Forbes Gamification Rajat Paharia SCRM Social Business social business software social enterprise social enterprise apps social technologies BrandWatch IBM Lotus iToilet LeWeb Loic Le Meur mobile Myzeo Seesmic Social CRM Yammer Zendesk application development application extension and usability Apps Strategy Box Box.net CIO cloud integration Cloud options Cloud Wars CoIT collaboration collaboration software Consumerization of IT emerging technologies Enterprise 2.0 Enterprise apps strategy Enterprise Business Apps Enterprise Business Apps Vendors enterprise class enterprise collaboration Microsoft online services vendor event Forrester Teleconference Jam Sessions vendor management 2009 analyst event Colorado Inside Intelligence SAS Insitute Steamboat Grand Steamboat Springs AI driven smart services #FFCommLive19 2019 accounting AI artificial intelligence best practices business transformation C-Suite CDO CEO cfo Chief Data Officer Chief Digital Officer Chief Executive Officer Chief Financial Officer Chief Information Officer Chief Information Security Officer Chief Innovation Officer Chief Procurement Officer Chief Revenue Officer Chief Sales Officer Chief Security Officer Chief Service Officer Chief Technology Officer Cloud ERP COO CTO Dan Brown data driven data driven digital network Data to Decisions Data2Decisions Digital Business Digital Disruption digital strategy digital transformation DigitalBiz digitaltransformation Enteprise Resource Planning Enterprise Enterprise Resource Planning ERP event report finance financial apps FinancialForce inventory management leadership News Analysis order management public cloud retail revenue recognition service billing subscription billing subscription revenues Tod Nielsen vendor strategy #digital 2020 acquisition acquisitions ambient experience ambient experiences B2C B2C E-commerce British Columbia Business continuity planning Change Agents Chief Customer Officer Chief Marketing Officer Cloud push CMO Commerce Commerce Cloud contactless commerce COVID-19 crowdsourcing customer experience Digital acceleration digital commerce digital monetization Digitize channels direct to consumer direct to consumer. pricing optimization disruptive business models Diversify supply chains dynamic feedback loops e-commerce event driven architectures events headless commerce marketing automation Matrix Commerce Mental health support mergers mergers and acquisitions microservices mobify open vs closed Perception and communications Personalization personalization at scale Salesforce Commere Cloud SalesForce.com Vancouver Apple Friday's Feature IFS iPod ue ui usability user experience user interaction ux dashboard environmental sustainability Microsoft Business Solutions Microsoft Dynamics AX Microsoft Dynamics NAV snapshots Contract Negotiations contract strategy IT Strategy license fees license policy maintenance fees Oracle PeopleSoft SAP Siebel software contract reviews software licensing software licesing and pricing software pricing baan Great Plains JD Edwards Lawson Software Lawson IBM IT Services IT services firms management consulting non-compete Price Waterhouse Coopers PWC system integrator 2008 Convergence Dynamics Project Green vendor events design phase governance implementation long term apps strategy OP=Q+R+S+T pmo program management CDC Software Epicor Financials JDA Software NetSuite Q1 QAD Quarterly Financial Tracker RightNow order management hubs Perfect Order Infor Trends vendor financing John Ragsdale reality check sales reps sales strategies Maintenance Hike software licensing and pricing software vendors stupid idea ISV's solution centric ecosystems Concur Deltek Quarterly Revenues middleware platforms PaaS cdi customer data integration Customer Hubs intiate scottsdale customer summit iGate indian data warehouse las vegas teradata Vendor Selection Customer Feedback Forrester Hike Maintenance UK and Ireland SAP Users Group UK bridgewater nj Siperian financial crisis hp intel sun long term apps strategies shelf ware Tuesday's Tip promotions Wednesday's Whispers initiate systems master data management MDM deployment options economic uncertainty economic recession packaged apps project portfolio shared services strategy vendor rationalization ppm primavera projectd based solutions Boston MA Progress Software Customer References Vendor Supplied Customer References consona mgm grand hotel palazzo sands expo venetitan smb ibm software group information management mandalay bay crm; san francisco Conference End User SAP User Groups UK and Ireland Atos Origin Compiere Deloitte Eisenberg Analyst Relations Infovide-Matrix job moves Motally TechTarget whispers credibility customer vendor contract economic downturn monday musings relationship management relationships trust vendor - client vendor - customer BPCs customer conference erp LN erp LX inforum Jim Schaper SyteLine vendors Implementation strategy Seven Habits Stephen R. Covey apps strategies CGI consortia blue wolf boomi cast iron systems informatica integration pervasive snap logic the "I" word business optimization IBM Cognos IBM Data Management IBM ECM Information Agenda Information On Demand InfoSphere recession proofing arhictecture construction foresight 2008 professional services project based solutions speaking engagement hcl orlando denver sage software Ariba Computer Associates Epicor Software i2 iLOG Intuit Taleo CODA force.com Glovia SFDC role of user groups SUGEN user groups users sourcing